Music Analysis for Musical
Grammars
The presentation’s main point is: all good pieces of
analysis are preliminary to the recognition of a grammar. The first part (“Analysis
in the forest of musical studies”) – pinpoints the location of analytical
studies in the broader field of various musical disciplines. Part 2 deals with
the different meanings of the concept ‘musical rule’, and reaches the
following statement: every kind of music – more or less provided with explicit
compositional directions – is based on a system of rules which belongs to a
grammar, common to different pieces by different composers acting in the same
epoch and genre. That is: every piece of music belongs to a grammar of a
particular style, because even in the most revolutionary piece of art, rules
do exist. In part 3 the concept of ‘grammar’ is discussed. This concept is
strictly related to the concept of rule because rules are the material of the grammar. The two concepts
are not equivalent, however: single rules have to be ordered and systematized
in order to become part of a grammar. Moreover, the nature of the rules
emerging from analysis (and the grammar to which they belong) must not be
confused with the kind of procedures which act when the rules are concretely
applied. In fact, a rule describes the functioning of a single phenomenon
(that is the facet of ‘knowledge’), but also sets limits on the use of the
phenomenon itself (the ‘operative’ facet). The central idea of grammar finds
its realisation in a conceptual tool able to ‘describe’ and to ‘utilise’ the
rules governing the coherent connections among all the elements constituting a
musical unit of a higher level. So, we can say that a grammar is in itself an ordered system of rules. A
grammar as a cognitive tool is an explicit and conceptual description of
grammatical competence. |